
Lessons learned – prioritising preventive measures after an accident
On board a large sea-going fishing vessel, the engineer was to repair a conveyor belt between the factory deck and the cargo hold. Access to the drive chain, which needed repair, was tight and difficult. Additionally, the cargo hold maintained a temperature of -30 degrees Celsius.
Due to the low temperature, there is a regular need for repair and maintenance, as ice forms and the material in the compartments becomes brittle and weak.
A frozen block of fish was stuck on the belt and had to be moved before the repair could begin. As the engineer was moving the block, it fell off the belt and grazed his head. It was not a particularly hard impact, and he continued working. When the engineer woke up the next day, he experienced reduced vision in his left eye. The situation worsened over the next few days.
At the next port of call, the engineer sought medical attention. After examinations, a retinal injury was detected, and the engineer was referred for surgery shortly thereafter.
Why did it happen?
On a vessel of this class, fish are processed directly from the trawl, through the factory, to the freezer/storage and should be ready to eat when they arrive on land and transported further. The Norwegian Food Safety Authority sets requirements for, among other things, freezing temperature and freezing time. The conveyor belt is considered a critical component in the production of fish on board. When this fails, it can lead to a halt in fishing, accumulation of fish in the factory and subsequent loss of raw material if it is not frozen quickly enough.
It is therefore a matter of maintaining hygiene on board, as well as an economic issue of getting production up and running as quickly as possible.
The accident report states that there was some urgency and time pressure to fix the conveyor belt. This is to be expected in such a situation. Conflicts of interest can quickly arise when balancing different considerations. In this case, between production/economy, food safety and personal safety.
In an ideal world, there is a comprehensive risk assessment and work procedure embedded in a safety management system to ensure safety in the work under all circumstances. The accident report indicates that they have a general risk assessment for the maintenance of such systems, and that the engineer has experience with repairing the conveyor belt.
“Maintenance of this has been thoroughly assessed verbally on several occasions, including the safety of the work," the report states.
Although reference is made here to both experience and planning around the task, it is difficult to account for the fact that one acts differently, makes different choices and prioritises differently when in a situation where there is urgency to get production going again. This is not necessarily anyone's fault, but a reality that may require finding other measures than those that can be accounted for in the design of the procedures and planning of the work.
What can be done?
Following this accident, the crew on both shifts discussed the incident, particularly the importance of emptying the conveyor belt before starting repair/maintenance.
This is naturally sensible, and it becomes even more effective if the experience is shared with other shifts and between other vessels in the fleet.
To address the conflicts of interest that arise in this incident, the accident report also describes an even more important measure: "We are considering various technical alternatives aimed at improving the operational reliability of the elevator (the conveyor belt, editor's note). This requires a longer workshop stay, during which the cargo hold will be heated and emptied. This will include searching for unknown misalignments and weaknesses."
Here, the shipping company proposes to rebuild the system in a way that helps avoid or delay the need for repairs. Not only could this contribute to increased uptime in production, but it also automatically reduces the risk for the crew on board by eliminating mechanical vulnerabilities that previously required human intervention to fix.
How to prioritise risk-reducing measures
Once a hazard is identified, eother through risk assessment or as a result of an unwanted incident – as in this case – preventive measures can be taken in various ways. However, some measures are more effective than others in reducing both the likelihood of exposure to the hazard and the consequences if exposure occurs.

For example, one can use the control hierarchy. Essentially, it is about understanding which "levels" of measures have the greatest effect for the most people, thereby reducing risk.
The figure shows the different levels, where eliminating risk by removing the need for exposure is the goal. In the hierarchy, personal protective equipment has the lowest effect. This does not mean that it is not important and critical to use personal protective equipment – the point is that measures at this level do not contribute to reducing the likelihood of exposure to danger.
If we place the measures implemented after the engineer on this fishing boat was injured, we can see that discussing the incident, sharing experiences and improving procedures are considered administrative measures. At the same time, it is understood that the long-term modifications aim to reduce the need for human intervention. If they succeed in this, they have largely eliminated the risk or postponed the need for exposure to risk. This truly shows that lessons have been learned from the incident.