
Navigational watch on fishing vessels – lessons learned
When incidents are reported, we often see that the direct cause is a lack of watchkeeping on the bridge.
LESSONS LEARNED: In this edition of "Lessons learned", we have picked out three teachable incidents. The incidents are different but they have one thing in common. All of them led to grounding due to lack of or disappearance of watchkeeping on the bridge.
Three groundings
The first incident involved a fishing vessels of approximately 20 metres that grounded and sank. The Norwegian Safety Investigation Authority has found that the master fell asleep before the accident, which happened at three in the morning. There was midnight sun in the area at the time of the accident, and the master was alone on the bridge. The reason why this happened was most likely a combination of three different factors: lack of sleep, fatigue due to the time of night and insomnia.
The second incident involved a fishing vessel that ran aground and was left hard aground with a list of 40 degrees. It was dark and there was a strong breeze. The incident report states that the cause was the attention being directed towards a fast ferry in the fairway, while the person on navigational watch was busy reporting the catch.
In the third incident, the ship's master fell ill while returning from the fishing grounds. He was alone when he lost conciousness and collapsed on the deck. He woke up as the vessel crashed ashore and realised they had run aground. On the way to shore, the crew had shared the navigation duties, each taking about two hours on navigational watch.
Cause assessment
Being sufficiently rested can depend on what the rest period has been spenty doing and the quality of sleep. Rest periods and watches characterised by noise, vibration, poor weather, little sleep or disturbances may lead to a challenging navigational watch. Other significant factors include the time of day and the crew of the navigational watch.
Decreasing daylight, monotonous tasks, low manning level, demanding work conditions, poor air quality on the bridge and long shifts can be underlying causes for crew members falling asleep on watch.
A low manning level and long, demaning shifts can also lead to the navigational watch having to perform multiple tasks simultaneously. This may take away focus from the navigation. Conversely, when there is little to do on the bridge, there is a risk that the navigational watch finds other "pastimes" that take focus away from navigation, such as mobile phones, computers, etc.
Last but not least, it is important to be prepared for the unexpected. In the third incident, it was a sudden illness that led to grounding. This is also something to consider in risk assessments for watchkeeping.
Lessons learned
A measure that contributes to increased safety is having at least two people on navigational watch with dedicated tasks. Navigational watch with at least two people should therefore be considered where it is not required.
If it is not possible to have two people on the bridge at all times, a bridge navigational alarm system can be a helpful tool. The bridge navigational alarm system does not function as a look-out but can prevent falling asleep on watch. It also alerts the rest of the crew if the person on navigational watch does not acknowledge the alarm for some reason.
Another useful tool is ECDIS (Electronic Chart Display and Information System), which can, among other things, give an alarm if the vessel leaves the planned sailing route or heads towards other dangers. This requires that the route is entered into the ECDIS.
Good routines for navigational watch is important. If there are few people on board, it may be necessary to complete reporting before the voyage from the field starts. Some shipping companies also prohibit the use of mobile phones on the bridge. This may not be a solution that suits everyone, but it is important that each shipping company establishes good routines that best suit their vessels.
Those responsible for navigation should have navigation and safe sailing as their main focus. If there are several people on the bridge, the distribution of roles and responsibilities must always be clarified.
A common understanding of the risk factors and measures, where the entire crew partisicpates in the assessment of tasks and the operation of the vessel, is important. This will create a better safety culture.
Key requirements related to fishing vessels
Fishing vessels of less than 50 gross tonnage in fjord fishing and in-shore fishing:
- Regulations on the working environment, health and safety of persons working on board ship, section 2-2
- Regulations on safety management for small cargo ships, passenger ships and fishing vessels, etc., sections 5 and 6
- Regulations on hours of work and rest on board fishing vessels
- Regulations for preventing collisions at sea (Rules of the Road at Sea), Rule 5. Look-out
- Regulations on qualifications and certificates for seafarers, section 6
Fishing vessels of less than 50 gross tonnage in trade area bank fishing or greater trade area:
- Regulations on watchkeeping for the deck and engine department on Norwegian fishing vessels
- Regulations on hours of work and rest on board fishing vessels
- Regulations on the working environment, health and safety of persons working on board ship
- Regulations on safety management for small cargo ships, passenger ships and fishing vessels, etc., sections 5 and 6
- Regulations for preventing collisions at sea (Rules of the Road at Sea) Rule 5. Look-out
- Regulations on qualifications and certificates for seafarers, section 6
Fishing vessels of 50 gross tonnage and upwards, all trade areas:
- Regulations on watchkeeping for the deck and engine department on Norwegian fishing vessels
- Regulations on hours of work and rest on board fishing vessels
- Regulations on the working environment, health and safety of persons working on board ship, section 2-2
- Regulations for preventing collisions at sea (Rules of the Road at Sea) Rule 5. Look-out
- Regulations on qualifications and certificates for seafarers, section 6
- Regulations on safety management for small cargo ships, passenger ships and fishing vessels, etc., (Gross tonnage of less than 500) sections 5 and 6
- Regulations on a safety management system for Norwegian ships and mobile offshore units, section 2 (Gross tonnage 500 and upwards)
- The ISM COde chapters 6 and 7